A dwelling has a use, not just a floor plan
A legal ADU needs the applicable approvals and a space that meets the requirements for residential use. SF Planning’s ADU guidance explains program choices and property-history issues.
I’d identify the actual approval pathway before estimating construction cost or rent. A quick sketch can show where a kitchen fits; it cannot establish that the city will approve the project.
The state and local pathways can differ
SF Planning distinguishes state and local programs, including different rent-control treatment and restrictions tied to some eviction histories. Which route fits depends on the property and project.
Hypothetical example: an investor plans to add a unit behind an existing garage. Access, existing use, building conditions, and the selected program can change feasibility. Ask for an architect’s code review and a realistic scope before assigning value to projected income.
Underwrite the completed, usable project
Separate planning, design, permits, construction, contingencies, and carrying costs. Then model rent after operating expenses and any financing. The investment should not depend on faster approvals or unusually aggressive rent growth.
Our investment underwriting guide provides the financial framework. If a unit already exists without clear approvals, start with unpermitted unit and the records, rather than assuming it is a new ADU project.
What to check
- Verify the current legal units and existing uses.
- Identify the applicable ADU program and rent rules.
- Budget permits, construction, carrying costs, and a downside case.