
The most expensive house-hacking mistake is buying income or possession you do not actually have. A seller’s projected rent and a future owner’s apartment are plans until the tenancy, records and purchase terms support them.
Caley and I acquired Linden Street vacant, which gave our project a different starting point from a fully occupied building. I would not copy that project’s logic onto a purchase that depends on someone moving out. Underwrite the building you can legally operate at closing.
The six red flags to resolve before removing protections
| Risk | Evidence to request | Buying response |
|---|---|---|
| Owner’s apartment is occupied | Leases, tenant history and supported possession terms | Resolve lawful occupancy before treating the unit as your home |
| Projected rents replace actual rents | Leases, amendments, payment history and service obligations | Use current collectible income in the base case |
| Unit count conflicts | 3R, plans, permit history and actual layout | Resolve the legal use before counting rent or loan eligibility |
| Shared repair is unpriced | Inspection, scope, bids and access requirements | Fund the work and carrying time, or change the price |
| Loan depends on assumptions | Property-specific lender review and documentation | Confirm income treatment, reserves and remaining conditions |
| Down payment consumes liquidity | Complete cash uses and adverse monthly budgets | Keep a funded reserve rather than relying on refinancing |
Living in the building does not erase tenant protections
A sale does not automatically end a tenancy. San Francisco’s owner and relative move-in rules have conditions that require property-specific review. Resolve any proposed owner occupancy with a qualified local attorney before relying on it. Lender occupancy requirements do not create a right to displace a tenant.
Keep market asking rents separate from the lawful rent of an occupied apartment. A renovation plan does not by itself reset rent or remove a tenancy. Review required services, parking, storage and utility charges alongside the base rent, especially when a seller’s income sheet combines them.
“Unwarranted” is not an income category
An attractive basement or attic is not automatically another legal apartment. Start with the City’s parcel and permit information, obtain the 3R and building records, and reconcile them with the actual layout. Do not ask your budget to depend on rent from space whose lawful use is unresolved.
Price the shared repair, not only your apartment
A roof, foundation, sewer or electrical problem can affect the entire property even if your own unit looks finished. Ask what must happen now, what can be maintained and what needs replacement later. Include access, occupied-unit coordination, permit work and a contingency in the scope. A small building still has whole-building expenses.
At Linden Street, kitchen, window and laundry improvements were practical parts of the project. Those visible upgrades do not replace the need to inspect shared systems on another building. Read the property checklist before the tour becomes a discussion only about finishes.
Do not spend your repair fund on the winning offer
Run the underwriting model at the expected purchase price, then reduce rent and interrupt a rental unit. Keep closing costs, initial work and retained cash separate. A price that uses every dollar may leave the building unaffordable before the first ordinary repair.
Keep the tax and exit stories separate
Living in one part of the building and renting another creates personal and rental uses. IRS Publication 527 explains that certain shared expenses must be allocated. Do not assume the whole building’s costs are deductible against rental income.
A future condo conversion, TIC sale or added ADU needs its own eligibility and economics. The purchase should survive without that exit. My recommendation is simple: resolve possession and legal units first, price the systems second, and set the offer ceiling only after funding the downside.
Explore the house-hacking series: definition and SFAR prices, sourcing, property checklist, underwriting model, Linden Street.
Common questions
Can I replace an existing tenant’s rent with market rent in my model?
Not just because you bought the building. Use the lawful in-place rent and obligations for occupied apartments, with any future change supported separately.
Can I assume an attic becomes another rental?
No. Confirm lawful use, permits, feasibility, cost and timing before assigning income. Improvements to attic space do not establish a legal apartment.